Tuesday, December 19, 2017

Some Thoughts on Today's Students

The recent discussion on the House version of the Tax Bill, where graduate students would have to pay tax on tuition, led to its collapse, but the reason was logic not the whining of students like those in Science who wrote:

As engaged members of the scientific community, we must urge our academic institutions to take action. Universities should lobby elected officials, make public statements, and amplify graduate student organization efforts. If the repeal of 117(d) passes into law, our top priority will then be reworking tuition schemes to protect graduate student research and teaching. However, while the tax bill is still in committee, we have a more pressing goal: to unequivocally oppose the repeal of 117(d). We can call our elected representatives [some of whom seem open to the change] to voice opposition, sign petitions, and advocate for safeguarding graduate studies. This legislation will devastate productivity and innovation in higher education. As a scientific community, it is our duty to embolden young people to think and create. We can never recuperate the costs of lost potential.

There is no description of the strategic risk to the country,  to the impact of foreign students who will be supported by tax dollars etc. These are just a bunch of millennials whose argument is that as "engaged members" to have the University urge Congress. No reasons why other than they "feel" it should be so. 

Where did logic go, rhetoric, or even basic grammar. We need a return of the Trivium, not the self serving sniffles of children whose view of the world is as an entity that owes them something. By the way, Congress did get to recognize that Yamamoto did go to Harvard and did send his forces to Pearl Harbor! That my young millennials is why we need to have more citizens partake productively of our tax payer funded Universities, despite their abusive overhead, due to prior Government mandates.